Metal Roof vs. Shingles: Which Is Better in Hot Climate?

by | Last updated Oct 28, 2024 | Roofing

Owning a home in a hot climate means you need to consider the type of roofing material that will be best suited for your home. The two most popular options available are metal roofs and shingles. Both have unique pros and cons, but which one is better in a hot climate?

Homes in hot climates need energy-efficient and sturdy roofing materials to withstand extreme temperatures and keep residents cozy despite the harsh weather. Metal roofs are better than shingles in these regards, but they must be properly insulated. It’s worth paying extra for insulated metal roofs in hot climates.

Here’s a more detailed discussion on the debate of metal roofs vs. shingles in hot climates. We’ll focus on heat reflection, energy efficiency, and durability.

Heat Reflection and Cooling Properties

When your roof absorbs significant heat in hot climates, your home becomes much harder to cool. In fact, your roof may be responsible for up to 50% of your home’s heat gain during summer.

If you’re looking for a roofing company in Lexington, Kentucky, then contact the team at Jacob’s Ladder today for a quote.

Request Quote Call (859) 379-9137

Many homeowners turn to heat-reflective roofing materials to combat this issue and create a more energy-efficient home.

Heat-reflective roofing materials are designed to bounce off sunlight so it doesn’t radiate into your home. That’s how you keep your home cooler and minimize the need for air conditioning.

These materials can reflect up to 90% of sunlight, reducing the heat your roof absorbs. As a result, your home gets cooler, and your roof lasts longer.

Are Metal Roofs Cooler than Shingles?

Metal roofs are popular because of their reflective properties. They reflect more sunlight than shingles, keeping your home cooler and reducing cooling costs.

In fact, metal roofs with specialized coatings can reflect most of the sun’s UV rays.

Cool roof coatings are excellent for metal roofs in hot climates, reflecting sunlight and heat while quickly releasing any absorbed heat.

This combination of properties makes metal roofs an excellent option for homes in hot climates.

Do Metal Roofs Attract Heat?

One criticism of metal roofs is that they can attract heat and make your home hotter. However, this is not entirely true.

While metal roofs can get hot to the touch in direct sunlight, they don’t transfer that heat into your home as much as shingles do.

Yes, metals are great heat conductors, but as long as you insulate your attic properly, the metal roof won’t transfer that heat into your living space.

Remember, metal roofs with specialized coatings can reflect significant sunlight and heat, keeping your home cooler.

Metal roofs feature low thermal mass, so they don’t retain heat like other materials. Therefore, when it gets cloudy or dark, your metal roof will cool down quickly.

Anyway, here’s how to reduce heat from a metal roof.

Shingles: Do They Retain More Heat?

Yes, shingles retain more heat than metal roofs. The dark color and material of shingles absorb the sun’s rays, making them much hotter to the touch compared to metal roofs. Here’s more: “Does a Black Roof Make Your House Hotter?

Shingles aren’t great thermal conductors, so heat doesn’t quickly reach your living space. The heat spreads into your interior slowly, and when cooler evenings set in, the rest escapes into the atmosphere.

While shingles may not transfer heat as quickly to your living space, they do keep it trapped in your home for longer periods, causing higher energy bills and a warmer house overall.

So, metal roofs are better at keeping your home cool than shingles.

However, if you live in a cold climate where retaining heat is more important than reflecting it, shingles may be a better option for you.

Heat Retention: Lighter Vs. Darker Shingles

You may have heard lighter shingles are better at keeping your home cool than darker ones. But is this true?

It’s partially true. Lighter shingles reflect more sunlight and heat, making them cooler than darker shingles. However, the difference isn’t significant enough to impact your home’s overall temperature.

In fact, the color of your shingles has a very small effect on your home’s heat retention compared to other factors, such as insulation and ventilation.

Metal Roof vs. Shingles Energy Efficiency

What makes a roof energy-efficient? It’s not just about heat retention or reflection but also about how well it insulates your home.

Metal roofs are often more energy-efficient than shingles because they have a higher solar reflectance and thermal emittance. They reflect more of the sun’s rays and release heat faster.

Metal roofs also have fewer seams and gaps for air to escape, making them more airtight and efficient. You only need to install them with insulation underneath to provide extra protection against outside temperatures..

Shingles: Energy Efficiency Considerations

Lighter shingles may be more beneficial for keeping your home cool if you live in a hot climate. However, if you don’t have insulation or proper ventilation, the color of your shingles won’t make much of a difference.

Ultimately, factors like climate, insulation, ventilation, and roof design play a larger role in a shingle roof’s energy efficiency than the shingle colors.

It’s worth noting that asphalt shingles aren’t as durable as metal roofs and may need to be replaced more often. This frequent replacement can negatively impact your home’s overall energy efficiency.

Metal roofs last over 50 years, while shingle roofs typically last around 20-30 years.

This difference in durability can affect your home’s energy efficiency in the long run. Replacing a roof more frequently means using more materials and resources, which hurts the environment.

Additionally, metal roofs are easier to recycle at the end of their lifespan, making them a more sustainable choice for your home.

In contrast, shingles are not as easily recycled and may, after being replaced, end up in landfills, contributing to pollution and waste.

Maintenance and Repair Costs: Metal vs. Shingle Roofs

It’s much costlier to install metal roofs than shingle roofs, but that’s true only if you consider the upfront costs. Shingle roofs often cost more in the long run as the perks of metal roofs, like durability and energy efficiency, accumulate.

Due to harsh weather, such as hail and stormy winds, shingles can become damaged or dislodged easily. Such damages demand costly repairs and replacements.

Shingles may also need to be replaced or repaired every few years due to wear and tear or fading color.

On the other hand, metal roofs are more durable and less susceptible to damage from extreme weather. They also have a longer lifespan, meaning fewer repairs and replacements are necessary over time.

They’re resistant to warping, cracking, and fire hazards. UV rays and harsh weather conditions will not adversely affect a metal roof’s appearance or performance

So, metal roofs don’t need regular maintenance like shingle roofs do. The only need occasional inspections and minor repairs.

Cost Comparison and Value Over Time: Metal vs. Shingle Roofs

Shingle roofs are cheaper to install upfront but require more frequent replacements and repairs, leading to higher costs over time. On average, a metal roof can last two times longer than shingles.

Metal roofs also provide better insulation and energy efficiency, reducing your home’s heating and cooling costs. They’re also resistant to moss, mold, and mildew growth, which can damage shingles over time.

Moreover, metal roofs can increase the resale value of your home. Potential buyers perceive the durability and longevity of a metal roof as an attractive feature, making it a valuable investment.

Aesthetic and Design Flexibility: Metal vs. Shingle Roofs

Looks matter a lot, and modern homeowners desire some design flexibility regarding their roofs. Shingle roofs are diverse in colors and styles, so they’re a popular choice for traditional homes.

Shingles beat metal roofs in this aspect. However, metal roofs now come in various colors and styles, mimicking the appearance of shingles or other traditional roofing materials.

But there’s a look that you can’t achieve no matter how creative you are with shingles. Metal roofs ooze a sleek, modern, and upscale aesthetic that’s hard to replicate with shingles.

Environmental Impact: Metal vs. Shingle Roofs

Eco politics are in full swing, and homeowners seek roofing options that reduce their carbon footprint. Shingle roofs fall short of their short lifespan and high replacement rates, resulting in excessive landfill waste.

Metal roofs have a significantly longer lifespan, reducing the need for replacements and waste generation. At the end of their lifespan, they’re also 100% recyclable, making them an eco-friendly choice.

Moreover, you can coat metal roofs with reflective finishes to reduce heat absorption and lower your home’s energy consumption. It’s good for the environment and your wallet!

Verdict: Metal vs. Shingle Roofs in Hot Areas

When living in a hot area, you must go for a roofing material that withstands high temperatures and extreme weather conditions is essential. You’ll also need to determine whether solar panels make your house cooler or hotter.

It’s obvious by now that metal roofs are more suitable for hot areas. They’re durable, heat-resistant, and energy-efficient. But if you live in a normal area, then we can debate on “Metal Roof vs. Shingles: Which Is Best for Your Home?

Your subscription is not active

Please visit the admin site to re-activate your subscription

Contact Us