How to Negotiate Property Damage with an Insurance Company?

by | Dec 19, 2023 | Preparation

It’s heartbreaking to deal with property damage after natural disasters or accidents. Whether due to natural disasters, accidents, or other unforeseen circumstances, the aftermath of property damage can leave homeowners feeling helpless and vulnerable. Negotiating with insurance companies can be an added burden during this difficult time, but it’s the only way to get the compensation you deserve.

To effectively negotiate property damage with insurance companies, report early and know what not to say to a home claims adjuster. Reporting the damage early helps prevent further damage, increasing the odds of a successful claim. Work with certified insurance claims and large loss specialists for the best results. 

This post is for you if you’re wondering, “How do insurance companies negotiate settlements?” It will highlight the importance of negotiating property damage settlements with insurance companies and cover tips on handling the process. 

Understanding the Process of Insurance Claims

Filing an insurance claim for property damage involves several steps. 

If you’re looking for a roofing company in Nicholasville, Kentucky, then contact the team at Jacob’s Ladder today for a quote.

Request Quote Call (859) 379-9137
  1. Firstly, you need to report the damage to your insurance company as soon as possible. 
  2. You’ll then get a visit from a claims adjuster, who assesses the damages and determines the extent of coverage under your policy. 
  3. The adjuster’s role is to investigate and evaluate damages whenever claims are made, ultimately negotiating settlements that don’t hurt the insurer’s profitability.

The role of insurance adjusters is to minimize the amount of money paid out for the claim. They can even try to get the insurance company out of paying a claim altogether.  

For example, they can argue to pay zero or the least possible restitution for mold damage by proving you were negligent. They can also argue that the damage you claim was not due to a covered peril. In other words, insurance adjusters aim to protect their company’s bottom line.

So, insurance companies negotiate settlements via their adjusters, who skillfully try to reduce the amount they must pay on a claim. Your best bet for getting fairly restituted is to negotiate with the skills of certified insurance claims and large-loss specialists.

Strategies for Negotiating Insurance Settlement after Property Damage

Contacting your insurance company for negotiations is never a good idea until you’ve thoroughly researched and prepared. You should always understand the terms and coverage of your policy before reporting damages.

Here are a few best practices to follow while negotiating an insurance settlement for property damage:

1. Documenting and Evaluating Damage

Thoroughly documenting damages is crucial for a strong claim. Photos, videos, and receipts are essential evidence. Ensure the following:

  • Photos and Videos: Capture the damage from various angles and distances to show the extent clearly.
  • Receipts and Invoices: Keep records of repair costs, replacement items, and any other expenses incurred due to the damage.

If you do not have the funds to do repairs and need your insurer to come in, you’ll need accurate estimates from a third party who won’t try to drive down the cost. Here’s where you’ll need an insurance claims master to assess the total damages professionally.

2. Knowing Your Policy Inside Out

If you’re a renter, at this point, you may need to answer, “Does renters insurance cover mold damage?”

Understanding every detail of your insurance policy is crucial for successful negotiations. Familiarize yourself with the terms and coverage, including any exclusions, to tell the covered perils and which evidence can support your claim.

Apart from noting any applicable deadlines, also look for clauses that might affect your claim, such as deductibles, coverage limits, and special provisions.

3. Presenting Your Case

Be quick and thorough when collecting evidence and filing your claim. After comprehensive documentation, present your case to your insurer using clear, concise language backed by solid evidence.

Brevity in these situations is like a golden charm. Refrain from giving away unnecessary details that could be misconstrued against your claim. Also, ensure you have all the supporting documents at hand before filing your claim.

Tips for Successful Negotiation on Property Damage Insurance Compensation 

1. Communicating Effectively

Maintain clear and respectful communication by:

  • Being clear: Use simple language to articulate your points.
  • Listening actively: Understand the adjuster’s perspective to find common ground.
  • Being respectful: Avoid being confrontational or aggressive.
  • Staying calm: It helps you present your case more effectively.

2. Providing Evidence

Provide all necessary evidence to support your claim. We already covered the importance of collecting evidence immediately after the incident, but it’s also essential to present it to your insurer in a clear and organized manner. Take the time to:

  • Label each piece of evidence with the date and time.
  • Organize all evidence chronologically.
  • Convince using audio-visual aids when necessary.

3. What Not to Say to a Home Claims Adjuster?

There are a few things you should avoid saying to your home claims adjuster. These include:

  • Admitting fault: Even if you internally believe you were responsible for the damages, never admit it to the adjuster. Let them make their own judgments based on the facts.
  • Exaggerating or downplaying damages: Be truthful and accurate when describing the extent of the damages.
  • Making assumptions about coverage: Let the adjuster determine coverage based on your policy rather than assuming what is covered. Only bring out your supported evaluations if you dispute the adjuster’s findings. 
  • Becoming emotional: Feeling frustrated or upset is understandable, but avoid getting rude or aggressive so you’re focused on the prize. Getting too emotional can hinder your ability to communicate effectively and may negatively impact the outcome of your claim.
  • Admitting you don’t have evidence: If you didn’t properly document the damages, don’t admit it to the adjuster. Instead, explain that you may not have all the necessary evidence at the moment and offer to provide it as soon as possible.

How Do Insurance Companies Negotiate Settlements?

Insurance companies are always thorough in their investigations when settling claims. They look at both sides of the story and gather as much evidence as possible to make an informed decision. Here are some ways insurance companies negotiate settlements:

  • Reviewing policy coverage: The adjuster will scrutinize the terms of your insurance policy to determine how much compensation you are entitled to, if any.
  • Investigating the damages: The insurance company will assess the extent of the damages and may hire a third-party contractor to inspect the property.
  • Considering liability: If there is any dispute over who is at fault for the damages, the adjuster will investigate and make a determination.
  • Settlement determination: They consider policy terms, precedents, and negotiations to arrive at a settlement figure.
  • Negotiating with the homeowner: After determining a settlement amount, the adjuster will negotiate with the homeowner to reach an agreement.
  • Comparing estimates: The adjuster will compare your estimate of damages with theirs, and if there are any discrepancies, they may request additional evidence or explanations.
  • Confirmation of settlement: Once both parties agree on a settlement amount, they put it down on paper and sign the agreement. 

Final Thoughts on Negotiating with Property Damage Insurers 

Insurers with a friendly homeowners insurance claims process are often easier to work with and have more flexible policies. However, it’s essential to appreciate that insurers are running a business whose primary goal is minimizing payouts. 

You’re best prepared when you understand how property damage insurance claims work, as it will help you negotiate better. Also, you can avoid making costly mistakes while communicating with the adjuster by knowing what not to say. 

It will increase your chances of receiving a fair settlement for your damages. Additionally, it’s crucial to communicate openly and transparently with the adjuster while being professional and courteous. 

Don’t hesitate to contact our team at Jacob’s Ladder for expert guidance if you need to negotiate insurance settlement for property damage in Nicholasville, KY, or surrounding areas.

Local Reviews
for Nicholasville, KY

Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 12 customer reviews

Map of Nicholasville, KY 40356

Fast and Professional




Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
NicholasvilleKY40356 37.8825-84.5675

The roof was leaking, but I couldn't find out from where. Called Jacob's Ladder, and they found out the cause from around the chimney and fixed it in no time!


Map of Nicholasville, KY 40356

Wonderful experience!




Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
NicholasvilleKY40356 37.875-84.5775

We had such a wonderful experience using Jacob’s Ladder. After contacting several different companies, they were the only ones who responded quickly and they had the best price. Would absolutely use again!


Map of Nicholasville, KY 40356

Fast and reliable




Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
NicholasvilleKY40356 37.89-84.55

Fast and reliable professional service!


Map of Nicholasville, KY 40356

Professional. Timely. Great Work




Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
NicholasvilleKY40356 37.88-84.59

They were very professional showed up when they said they were going to and completed the job in a timely manner. I would recommend this company to anyone they do good work.


Map of Nicholasville, KY 40356

Two thumbs up




Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
NicholasvilleKY40356 37.8925-84.58

Friendly, courteous office personnel. Knowledgeable roof inspector. Timely scheduling. Efficient workers who left the site near, clean, and free of debris! Two thumbs up on the whole experience!


Map of Nicholasville, KY 40356

I would highly recommend Jacob’s Ladder




Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
NicholasvilleKY40356 37.8475-84.5675

Andrea was Great and everyone else I talked with there. I got a new roof and the whole process was done professionally. They did a great job on the roof and cleaned up very well around the house. I would highly recommend Jacob’s Ladder.


Map of Nicholasville, KY 40356

Very happy




Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
NicholasvilleKY40356 37.8775-84.5675

Very happy with the services, they did a great job with the roof, clean-up, and communications.


Map of Nicholasville, KY 40356

Quick Turn Around




Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
NicholasvilleKY40356 37.855-84.58

We have some shingles blow off in the recent storm. Jacob's Ladder helped us out, worked with our insurance, and turned the job around quickly. Thanks!


Map of Nicholasville, KY 40356

Professional and helpful




Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
NicholasvilleKY40356 37.9-84.57

Contacted Jacobs Ladder to have my roof replaced. Very professional and very helpful with all the questions I had regarding my roof. New roof looks great! Thanks again


Map of Nicholasville, KY 40356

Roof Replacement for a townhouse




Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
NicholasvilleKY40356 37.9-84.57

From start to finish, every contact with this company was extremely professional and pleasant. They were replacing a roof next door to us and I inquired about doing some repairs. After inspecting our roof, they recommended filing an insurance claim for a full replacement. The owner of the company worked closely with us and went above and beyond when our claim was initially denied. The work crew was prompt, courteous and efficient. The end result was a beautiful new roof. They even filed our warranty paperwork with Owens Corning. It was a pleasure doing business with Jacob's Ladder. Highly recommended for their professionalism and personal touch every step of the way!

Contact Us