Do I Need a New Roof, or Can I Get Away with a Repair?

by | Sep 25, 2023 | Roofing

As a homeowner in Kentucky, you know how important a roof is for protecting your home and family from the elements. But when it comes to maintaining your roof, you may face a dilemma: Do I need a new roof, or can I get away with just repairing it?

You’ll need either repairs or roof replacement, depending on the condition of your roof and how much damage it has suffered. Generally, you’ll need a new roof if the current one is over 20 years old and has sustained significant damage. Repairs may work, but not when your roof’s structural integrity is breached.

Let’s discuss the tell-tale signs to help you know when to act, as we define the two remedies in more detail. We’ll even outline the steps to take if you need a new roof or repairs.

What Are the Common Signs of Roof Damage or Wear and Tear?

1. Leaks and Water Damage

The most apparent sign is water dripping through your ceiling or walls. When the water seeps into the roof structure over time, you’ll have to contend with structural damage and mold growth.

If you’re looking for a roofing company in Lexington, Kentucky, then contact the team at Jacob’s Ladder today for a quote.

Request Quote Call (859) 379-9137

2. Missing or Damaged Shingles

Cracked, curled, or missing shingles clearly indicate roof wear. These vulnerabilities expose your roof to further damage from the elements.

3. Sagging or Uneven Roof Lines

A sagging roof or areas with uneven lines can suggest underlying structural issues that need immediate attention.

4. Increased Energy Bills

A deteriorating roof can lead to poor insulation and increased energy consumption as your HVAC system struggles to maintain the desired temperature.

What Is the Importance of Regular Roof Inspections?

Regular roof inspections are crucial for identifying problems early and preventing costly damage. Here’s why inspections matter:

1. Early Detection

Inspections catch issues before they escalate, saving you money on major repairs or replacements.

2. Prevent Water Damage

By addressing leaks promptly, you prevent water damage to your home’s interior and potential mold growth.

3. Extending Roof Lifespan

Routinely maintaining and repairing your roof can extend its lifespan, making the most out of your investment.

Roof Repair vs. Roof Replacement

What Is Roof Repair?

Roof repair involves fixing specific issues, such as damaged shingles or leaks, without replacing the entire roof.

What Is Roof Replacement?

Requires removing the existing roof and installing a new one, typically due to extensive damage or an old roof.

The Factors to Consider for Roof Repair vs. Roof Replacement

1. Age of the Roof

Older roofs may require replacement, while newer ones might be suitable for repair.

2. Extent of Damage

The severity and extent of damage determine whether repair is sufficient or replacement is necessary.

3. Budget Constraints

Roof replacement is costlier than repair, so your budget could easily incline your preferences toward repairs.

4. Long-term Goals

Consider your long-term plans for the property. If you plan to sell soon, a new roof can increase the property’s value.

Potential Real-Life Example

Imagine you’re a regular homeowner with a 20-year-old roof experiencing leaks. You’d like to consider your budget, which allows for either a repair or replacement. Let’s say you also planned to sell the house in a few years.

After a thorough inspection, you could opt for a roof repair to address the leaks and increase the property’s resale value while staying within your budget.

The Advantages of Roof Repair

1. Cost-Effectiveness

Roof repair is generally more budget-friendly than a full replacement.

2. Faster Turnaround Time

Repairs are quicker to complete, minimizing disruption to your daily life.

3. Addressing Specific Issues

You can target and fix specific problems without the expense of replacing the entire roof.

4. Extending Roof Life

Proper repairs can extend the lifespan of your existing roof, postponing the need for replacement.

Scenarios for Roof Repair

Roof repair is ideal when:

  • Damage is localized and not extensive.
  • Your budget is limited.
  • You plan to sell your property in the near future.
  • The roof is relatively new and in good overall condition.

Also, as we explained in a previous post, keep and eye out for the three signs you need roof repairs.

The Roof Repair Process: Steps in a Typical Roof Repair Project

If you end up deciding for a roof repair, this is the procedure to follow:

1. Inspection and Assessment

A professional roofer assesses the damage and identifies the scope of repairs needed.

2. Shingle Replacement or Patching

Damaged shingles are replaced or patched to stop leaks.

3. Waterproofing and Sealing

Sealants and waterproofing materials are applied to vulnerable areas to prevent future leaks.

The Importance of Hiring a Professional

Professional roofing contractors are essential for repairs because they:

  • Ensure safety during repairs.
  • Have the expertise to identify underlying issues.
  • Use quality materials and techniques.
  • Offer warranties on their work.

Here’s how to find a roof repair specialist. 

The Advantages of a New Roof

1. Enhanced Durability

A new roof offers better resistance to weather elements and damage, increasing its lifespan.

2. Increased Energy Efficiency

Modern roofing materials improve insulation, leading to lower energy bills.

3. Improved Aesthetics

A new roof can enhance your home’s curb appeal and overall appearance.

4. Property Value Increase

A new roof adds value to your property, making it more attractive to potential buyers.

When to Invest in a New Roof

A new roof is best when:

  • Your current roof is old and nearing the end of its lifespan.
  • Extensive damage exists that cannot be effectively repaired.
  • You plan to stay in your home long-term.
  • You want to enhance your home’s energy efficiency and appearance.

The Roof Replacement Process

The following are steps to follow in a roof replacement project:

1. Tear-off of Old Roofing Materials

The old roofing material is removed down to the decking.

2. Installation of New Roofing Materials

New shingles or roofing materials are installed, along with necessary underlayment and flashing.

3. Inspection and Quality Checks

A final inspection ensures proper installation and quality workmanship.

What Is the Importance of Proper Installation and Materials?

Proper installation and quality materials are vital for a long-lasting, well-performing roof. Skimping on these aspects can lead to premature issues and costly repairs.

Tips for Selecting a Reputable Roofing Contractor

1. Check Licenses and Insurance

It will help you conduct due diligence to ensure your contractors are licensed and insured to work in your area.

2. Ask for References and Reviews

Request references from previous customers and read online reviews to gauge their reputation.

3. Obtain Detailed Estimates

Get written estimates that outline the scope of work, materials, and costs.

Role of a Trustworthy Contractor

A trustworthy contractor plays a pivotal role in the decision-making process by:

  • Providing expert guidance on repair or replacement.
  • Ensuring the chosen option is executed correctly.
  • Sourcing quality raw materials and adhering to industry standards.
  • Offering warranties that give you peace of mind regarding the work performed.

Verdict: Roof Repair vs New Roof

Whether you should repair your roof or opt for a replacement depends on various factors such as the extent of damage, age of the existing roof, and budget. Consulting with a qualified and experienced contractor helps to make an informed decision.

If you need roof repair in Kentucky, contact us. We offer reliable services, high-quality products, competitive rates, and expert installation to help you extend the lifespan of your roof and protect your home for many years to come. 

Local Reviews
for Lexington, KY

Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 9 customer reviews

Map of Lexington, KY 40502

Glad we chose them

Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
LexingtonKY40502 37.9975-84.485

We recently had Jacob’s Ladder replace our roof, and I’m really glad we chose them. They were professional and really attentive to detail. Andrea and Lisa were great at keeping us informed throughout the process. They even checked in with us multiple times to make sure we were happy with how things were going.

Map of Lexington, KY 40517

Very Satisfied!

Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
LexingtonKY40517 37.9875-84.515

Jacob's Ladder did a roof replacement job for a shed in my Backyard. I am very much satisfied with their work and definitely recommend them for all of your roofing needs.

Map of Lexington, KY 40503

Great Company!

Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
LexingtonKY40503 38.01-84.5575

Great Company to Work with Very Professional did a really nice job on our House and our Barn.

Map of Lexington, KY 40505


Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
LexingtonKY40505 38.0875-84.46

Everyone was wonderful from start to finish!

Map of Lexington, KY 40517

Their work is so good it withstood the 100 mph plus winds!

Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
LexingtonKY40517 37.9825-84.52

In May of 2022 a very damaging hail and windstorm pretty much destroyed my entire roof in Lexington Kentucky. Due to an insurance company that did not want to pay Jacobs Ladder was able to negotiate payment for an entirely new roof, decking and all which now meets current codes. Final work was completed January of 2023. Now my roof which leaked into my kitchen from May 2022 through December of 2022 has ceased to leak onto my kitchen floor. Their work is so good it withstood the 100 mph plus winds of 3rd March 2023.

Map of Lexington, KY 40505

All around #1 business!!

Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
LexingtonKY40505 38.065-84.455

Easy to communicate with, professional, cleaned up after working. All around #1 business!! I recommend Jacob’s Ladder for all your related needs, they’re very friendly and treat you right!

Map of Lexington, KY 40503

Very pleased with the roof!

Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
LexingtonKY40503 37.9875-84.555

Map of Lexington, KY 40503

Roof Repair Completed

Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
LexingtonKY40503 38.01-84.5075

Map of Lexington, KY 40504

Easy Insurance Claim!

Review of Jacob's Ladder Roofing and Restoration
LexingtonKY40504 38.0375-84.5425

Jacob’s Ladder did a great job for us. They where easy to contact, knowledge in handling Insurance claim did our job in a timely manner and left no mess behind. Very pleased.

Contact Us